Australia | Oct 20 2022
This story features WOOLWORTHS GROUP LIMITED. For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: WOW
Consumers are back in force, drinking and eating and losing money in pubs. Will it last?
-Pubs surge as bottle shops wane for Endeavour Group
-Premium drinks still in vogue
-Bumper Christmas ahead
By Greg Peel
A year ago NSW and Victoria were in delta lockdown, closing some 40% of Endeavour Group’s hotels nationally, while bottle shops BWS and Dan Murphy’s remained open. Unsurprisingly, consumers flocked to bottle shops.
A year on, hotels are open again, and a burning desire to socialise after two years of imprisonment has been unleashed. Endeavour reported a -6.2% fall in Retail (bottle shop) sales in the September quarter, but a whopping 91% growth in hotel sales as we all flocked back to pubs.
The fall in Retail sales included a not unsurprising -30% drop in online sales.
When pubs reopened, the diehards initially rushed back to the pokies, but that burst has eased off. The September quarter featured strong sales in Bar & Food, outpacing gaming. The number of people per booking rose 10%, and Endeavour reports the number of Christmas bookings is double what it was last year, with a third of capacity already booked.
The company has thus been stocking up for a bumper Christmas.
Cost of Living?
There may yet be an issue with staff shortages during Christmas, but management has assured they have it under control.
What most surprised analysts in the update is that despite inflation and the rising cost of living, pub-drinkers are still going for the higher-priced new, premium, low/no alcohol, craft and local products, when one might have expected a shift down the scale to lower-priced familiar beer brands and “house” wines.
Endeavour reported inflation of 4% across the industry, which is surprisingly low given food inflation.
Will it Last?
Australians suffered two Christmas periods of lockdowns and international and state border closures which prohibited the usual family get-togethers. For many, the last two Christmases have been sombre times.
This would explain why everyone wants to get out and party, and why we’re happy to spend up on the fancy stuff, this Christmas/New Year. But what happens after that?
The 2023 hangover?
Here, opinions are split. With uncertainty in mind, Endeavour has not provided FY23 guidance.
Morgans (Hold) suggests trading beyond Christmas will be “more unknown”. Macquarie retains an Outperform recommendation, but remains cautious on the outlook for the consumer into calendar 2023 with rising rates and inflation impacting household budgets.
Macquarie otherwise prefers consumer staples, which strangely includes Endeavour, over consumer discretionary.
The key unknown remains margins, suggests Morgans, with elevated costs related to supply chain, labour and technology expected to persist in the second half of FY23. Management also noted promotional activity remains strong, which keeps the broker relatively cautious on earnings despite ongoing revenue momentum.
Ord Minnett has not offered a view beyond Christmas, but retains a Buy. Perversely, Credit Suisse is the most positive, expecting acceleration in domestic leisure-related expenditure to be a recurrent theme through FY23, but this broker retains Underperform.
UBS turns to valuation to inform its Sell rating. The stock is trading at a 22.7x forecast PE multiple, which is an 8% premium to the ASX200 Industrials ex-Financials, when the average is a -5% discount, and a -2% discount to former owner Woolworths ((WOW)), when the average is -10%.
The Wilkie Factor
Credit Suisse believes one risk the market is not fully pricing in is that of pre-commitment loss-limits for pokie players. The Tasmanian government has decided to impose mandatory limits, but to date is the only state to do so.
Were other states to do the same, gaming revenues would be impacted.
Management stated it remains highly engaged with state governments and regulators on the issue, although it would not be drawn on the potential implications of the Tasmanian decision should it be replicated in some form on the mainland.
Credit Suisse sees wider implementation as being low probability, but a large tail risk.
Put it all together and Endeavour Group has drawn two Buy or equivalent ratings, one Hold and two Sells from the five FNArena database brokers covering the stock.
A wide range of target prices underscores uncertainty, from UBS’ $6.75 to Ord Minnett’s $8.20, for an average $7.32 (last trade $7.12).
The stock is forecast to offer a 3.0% FY23 yield, but you can lend your money to the government for two years risk-free and get 3.3% currently, albeit not franked.
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.
FNArena is proud about its track record and past achievements: Ten Years On
Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms
For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: WOW - WOOLWORTHS GROUP LIMITED