Australia | Jul 02 2019
Brokers acknowledge the effort made by South32 to turn around the Illawarra Coal operations. Nevertheless, a return to three longwalls requires a substantial lift in development rates.
-New enterprise agreements helping to optimise operations
-Higher coal prices have enabled South32 to address issues at Appin
-Dendrobium extension likely to consume considerable capital
By Eva Brocklehurst
South32 ((S32)) is motivated to improve its Illawarra Coal asset at Appin, NSW, conducting a site visit and showcasing plans to return to a three-longwall operation. The asset has a high fixed cost base and its success will be predicated on an ability to restore production levels to a targeted 8mtpa by FY21.
A key feature of the showcase was new enterprise agreements, as costs remain high, with labour contracts accounting for 50%. Ord Minnett notes the company intends to continue optimising its operations, which may take time given the importance of the mine to the community and a heavily unionised workforce.
Illawarra Coal's quality is sound but the assets are ageing and there is extensive infrastructure to maintain, both underground and on surface. Citi also notes management/labour relations have historically been difficult but South 32 has worked hard to finalise new enterprise agreements that have improved its right to manage.
Deutsche Bank, overall, was pleased with the turnaround in operations at the Appin underground coal mine although remains disappointed about the outlook for costs and capital expenditure.
The mine has a long production history but has been volatile over recent years. Peak production of 9mt was achieved in FY15 but had fallen by more than -50% by FY18. This reflected the problems with the ramping up of the Appin 9 longwall mine, as the company was unable to operate both longwalls in parallel, largely because of elevated gas levels.
South32 has now reconfigured Appin's operations to reduce its footprint and complexity. UBS was disappointed with the Appin mine after the decision to run two longwalls, as low coal prices exacerbated the problems with the simultaneous operation. However, higher coal prices have now allowed management to address the issues and production over FY19 exceeded original expectations. Guidance has been lifted to 6.5mt.
Five development units are currently operating and Citi envisages this is the biggest risk for a two-longwall operation at Appin, given historical development rates. Macquarie agrees. The ability of the company to return to a three-longwall operation requires a material lift in development rates and the broker's production forecasts remain below guidance until this is achieved.
The Dendrobium project expenditure, which extends the mine by 12 years, is budgeted at US$650-800m, well ahead of most broker estimates. UBS calculates the extension could mean capital expenditure is closer to US$250-300m per annum. Studies will continue for another year.
Citi assesses sustaining capital expenditure of around US$30/t. The broker considers this is high for an 8mtpa production outcome, as the company is running substantial service infrastructure and a large workforce.
The capital intensity of the project could deliver an internal rate of return of only 11.4%, yet Ord Minnett suspects there is some incentive in terms of the whole operation. While the project does not pass a typical return hurdle when viewed in isolation, if the company did not proceed, there would be a negative unit cost at Appin, as 80% of Illawarra Coal's costs are fixed.
Macquarie expects the company will proceed with the extension but, given the capital expenditure budget, assesses Illawarra Coal will now be a consumer of cash as opposed to a positive contributor to group cash flow. Cumulatively, over the next five years the broker expects capital Illawarra Coal will consume US$460m in cash versus a positive US$570m contribution to cash flow previously.
Going forward, Credit Suisse suggests the next catalyst will be further details on capital management as well as the June quarter production outcome. Cash will need to be deployed towards Eagle Downs, with an investment decision possible in the second half of 2020. While not modelling beyond the current program of buybacks, which is almost complete, Credit Suisse assesses plenty of scope for further distributions.
FNArena's database has five Buy ratings and three Hold for South32. The consensus target is $3.70, suggesting 13.1% upside to the last share price. Targets range from $3.20 (Macquarie) to $4.10 (Deutsche Bank). The dividend yield on FY19 and FY20 forecasts, at current FX values, is 5.1% and 4.5% respectively.
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.
FNArena is proud about its track record and past achievements: Ten Years On