Weekly Reports | Nov 05 2020
This story features EAST 33 LIMITED, and other companies. For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: E33
The New Criterion's Tim Boreham evaluates the latest seafood IPO and existing stocks.
By Tim Boreham, Editor, The New Criterion
If an upcoming IPO has its way, dinner party guests will need to contend with oyster aficionados raving on about creaminess and mouth feel along with the wine swillers, olive oil purists and crema-obsessed coffee snobs.
By making a splash into the underappreciated Sydney rock oyster pond, East 33 ((E33)) wants to be seen not so much as yet another ASX aquaculture entrant, but a prestige provenance play in the same style as the great French champagne houses.
That’s shucking news indeed.
Named in deference to the harbour city’s latitude, East 33 is all about consolidating rare and ancient growing leases into a scale entity with the financial firepower to market the world’s rarest oyster globally.
East 33 is in the throes of raising $32m of equity and a further $10m of debt to fund its plan to boost its market share from 9%-25%.
As their name implies, the royal-purple tinted shellfish are only grown in NSW estuaries and 85% of the catch is sold within the waratah state.
The Sydney oysters have a long history as a nutritious staple for indigenous people, dating back thousands of years. As a native species, the Sydney oysters are less prevalent to disease than the introduced Pacific oyster, which is far more widely consumed.
The growing leases rarely change hands and have been held by the same families since as early as 1884.
“These are irreplaceable assets, there are no more of them coming,” says East 33 co-founder and executive chairman James Garton.
Last year the company bought out four of the leaseholders and has agreed to buy out another six. However, these families continue to be involved, with second-generation farmer Stephen Verdich to become head of farming operations.
While 120 billion oysters are produced worldwide every year, only 640m end up as live exports, with Australian oysters (mainly Pacific oysters) accounting for a mere 1%.
Insomuch as exclusivity equates to rarity, East 33 is in promising waters given only about 75m are Sydney oysters are produced each year.
The oysters can only be grown at 41 locations and only nine have export approvals. Of these, five of these are at Wallis Lake and East 33 now controls four of them.
To date, appreciating rock oyster pricing hasn’t provided the usual signal for the fragmented grower base to increase output because they don’t share enough of the spoils.
In a posh restaurant in China, one Australian oyster can cost $10 or more.
Legendary Sydney seafood eatery Doyles charges $13.50 for a plate of three from Lemon Tree Passage, while swish Rockpool charges $6 each for a Wallis Lake-sourced bivalve (albeit with mignonette sauce).
But ‘farm gate’ returns vary between 55c and 93c per oyster, depending on the size, which means most of the value is being captured by the restaurateurs and other middlemen.
East 33 strives to inject corporate expertise into what’s essentially a cottage industry lacking reach across the valuable bits of the supply chain.
It’s no coincidence the East 33 board includes two former executives from the luxury goods group LVMH (Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton).
“But once you unleash the overseas demand for a luxury seafood product you had better be ready to meet the market,” Garton says.
East 33 managed underlying earnings (ebitda) of $5.2m on revenue of $26.8min the 2019-20 year. The company takes a stab at revenue of $40.2m and earnings of $8m by 2021-22, with output soaring from 4m oysters to 15m.
East 33’s raising is due to close on November 16, in view of a December 3 listing.
Murray Cod Australia ((MCA))
As a grower of premium seafood indigenous to NSW, Murray Cod draws obvious comparisons with the East 33 story. Providently, the Griffith based outfit’s shares have more than tripled since the company’s January 2017 ASX debut.
Shortly after listing management realised that the company needed a premium brand to distinguish itself from inferior cod in the market, characterised by an unpleasant earthy taste due to inadequate water management.
Hence, the product is known as Aquna – “flowing waters” in the indigenous tongue – and supported by a cabal of chefs including shareholder Heston Blumethal, Tetsuya Wakuda, Peter Gilmore and Josh Niland.
Having acquired another hatchery and launched plans to supersize its existing ponds, Murray Cod is on a quest to supersize its capacity from 1000 tonnes now to 10,000t by 2030.
At the time of the IPO the company was only selling 40 tonnes.
“It takes us two years to grow a fish but the demand for the fish is just fantastic,” says executive chairman Ross Anderson. “We call it a get-rich-slowly scheme.”
Murray Cod occurs only in the Murray Darling Basin and commercial fishing of the depleted wild population is banned.
Currently, about 25% of the output is exported, up from virtually nothing a year ago.
“Our exports will end up being 90-95% of our volume,” Mr Anderson says.
Currently, the local market for Murray Cod amounts to a mere 100 tonnes annually, a drop in the river compared with the 22,000t of barramundi (mainly imported) we chomp through.
Angel Seafood ((AS1))
Pacific oysters may have been introduced here but Angel grows them in abundance on South Australia’s Eyre Peninsula.
The Thorney Investments backed grower claims to be the southern hemisphere’s biggest sustainable and organic certified Pacific oyster grower – and we’re not arguing with that.
While Angel shares are adrift of their 20c IPO price in February 2018, the company is a positive portent for East 33 in terms of being able to scale up production and crack export markets.
Angel churned out a record 2.7m oysters in the September quarter, up 78% and also recorded positive cash flow of $408,000. Angel’s $4.5m of revenue to date already exceeds the calendar 2019 tally of $4.3m.
The company has an inventory of 22m oysters in the water.
Angel uses a multi-bay approach, which each one exhibiting differing growing characteristics such as water flow rates, nutrition and temperature.
This approach hedged against the risk of the entire crop being wiped out by disease.
As well as their famed aphrodisiac qualities, oysters are also rich in zinc, protein, vitamin D and Omega-3 fatty acids.
You either love’ em or you loathe ‘em, though.
Disclaimer: Under no circumstances have there been any inducements or like made by the company mentioned to either IIR or the author. The views here are independent and have no nexus to IIR’s core research offering. The views here are not recommendations and should not be considered as general advice in terms of stock recommendations in the ordinary sense.
Content included in this article is not by association the view of FNArena (see our disclaimer).
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.
FNArena is proud about its track record and past achievements: Ten Years On