Australia | May 13 2019
Despite a hostile housing environment, REA Group posted a robust March quarter, improving its depth penetration and take-up of new products.
-REA Group still expects the rate of revenue growth to exceed the rate of cost growth over FY19
-Has online depth penetration reached a ceiling?
-Financing business decline expected to continue into FY20
By Eva Brocklehurst
Brokers consider REA Group ((REA)) posted a strong outcome in the March quarter, offsetting the decline in residential listings with price rises, improved depth penetration and the take-up of new products.
Continued switching of residential agents to Premiere All subscription plans has more than offset the fall in volumes of new listings in the March quarter. Excluding associate losses, earnings growth of 6% was achieved in the quarter despite a volume decline of -9%. Overseas associate losses will be higher in FY19 because of the recently-acquired leads referral business, OpCity.
Listings weakness is expected to be severe in the fourth quarter – April volumes were down -22% nationally – because of the timing of holidays and the federal election. Countering the ups and downs, Ord Minnett points out the company has built a network that is resilient and it continues to command substantial pricing power.
Still, the penetration of premium advertising has reached around 18%, which the broker believes is close to the 20-25% ceiling it ascribes for depth products on online platforms in general and this could limit further revenue growth. REA is more confident, believing it has "several more" years of growth in Premiere All and is nowhere near full penetration.
Market conditions may not be expected to improve in the short term but these are unusual circumstances, with a combination of weak property markets and a federal election looming, and Macquarie points out the company still expects the rate of revenue growth to exceed the rate of cost growth over the full year.
The broker expects a rebound in depth revenue from the first half of FY20 amid improving volumes. Depth penetration growth in absolute terms is likely to moderate as the cycle turns, Macquarie assesses, as some of the growth in depth penetration is counter-cyclical.
Morgans is also optimistic, despite the worst residential listing environment in decades. The company has now implemented larger-than-expected price rises for FY20 and the broker upgrades forecasts and valuation.
Most of surprises in the March quarter came from tight cost controls amid a record penetration rate for depth plans. The broker acknowledges the risks lie in the steep falls in Australian residential listing volumes, amid potential for new product initiatives to fail to find widespread acceptance.
Still potential near-term re-rating catalysts include better results from Asian and US operations and success in lifting the volume of home loans through the new financial services initiative. Morgans expects a few years of double-digit earnings growth and very high levels of free cash generation, which should underpin increases in dividends.
Credit Suisse found the results reasonable, although the numbers are tracking behind its forecasts for 8.5% growth in revenue and 5.5% in operating earnings (EBITDA) in FY19. Still, the broker notes REA Group is continuing to outperform rival Domain Holdings ((DHG)).
Ord Minnett expects listing volumes to decline -13% in the second half and also lowers depth penetration estimates based on channel checks. Price growth expectations have been reduced to 8% from 10% for FY20. As a result, the broker downgrades FY19 operating earnings estimates to $524.5m from $526.2m previously.
Developer, Commercial Growth
Developer and commercial business grew firmly, benefiting from increased project profile duration and spending on display advertising by developers. The company has also reached a new partnership deal to expand the reach of Juwai in China. Juwai markets international properties, mostly in Australasia, to Chinese investors.
The financing business declined because of tighter lending conditions and uncertainty in the property market and similar conditions are anticipated over the remainder FY19 and into FY20. Ord Minnett lowers FY20 first half mortgage services growth estimates to flat, as a decline in mortgage settlements is expected to continue.
FNArena's database shows four Buy ratings, two Hold and one Sell (Ord Minnett). The consensus target is $86.29, signalling 4.4% upside to the last share price. Targets range from $71 (Ord Minnett) to $105 (Citi, yet to update on the quarterly).
See also, Property Slowdown Hampers REA Group on February 11, 2019.
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.
FNArena is proud about its track record and past achievements: Ten Years On