article 3 months old

Wesfarmers Opts For A Tighter Strategy

Australia | Jun 08 2018

This story features WESFARMERS LIMITED. For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: WES

Wesfarmers is taking on more disciplined approach to future capital deployment and brokers believe management is signalling a preference for a smaller, better-returning base.

-Target contracting to a smaller, more focused fashion business
-Opportunities in industrial segments may be underappreciated
-Capital returns considered less likely until divestments are sorted

 

By Eva Brocklehurst

After offloading its loss-making venture with Homebase, Wesfarmers ((WES)) has emphasised capital discipline at its strategy briefing. Brokers welcome the change of focus, as management watered down expectations that further M&A may be imminent.

Deutsche Bank is pleased that a disciplined approach is being applied to future capital deployment, noting the CEO has signalled the existing businesses represent the best opportunity to invest.

The focus will be on shareholder returns and the broker is left with the impression that management would be content with running a smaller, better-returning capital base if the right M&A opportunity does not present.

A -20% reduction in Target floor space is planned over the next five years as well as the ramping up of private label products and refurbishments at Coles. Morgans believes management is doing a good job repositioning the portfolio and re-weighting it towards stronger growth and higher-returning businesses.

The CEO has signalled his main priorities, since taking over as managing director, are making a decision on Homebase, improving the performance of department stores and re-weighting the portfolio. The de-merger of Coles and the sale of Homebase are viewed as consistent with this strategy.

Macquarie points to a further emphasis on big data and FlyBuys. Wesfarmers and Coles will each have a 50% stake in FlyBuys post de-merger and have opened an analytics centre in Melbourne with a view to support best-practice data analytics.

Credit Suisse downgrades to Neutral from Outperform, given the recent appreciation in the share price and despite the near-term catalysts. Still, the broker envisages no lack of attractive internal opportunities to support improving returns.

As Target contracts to a smaller, more focused fashion business the capital deployed should reduce in parallel with improved profits. The scale of Kmart will be hard for other entrants to the market to overcome, while the broker suggests talk of offshore expansion in the long-term is likely to come to nothing.

Credit Suisse further suggests the opportunities in industrial segments are underappreciated. Chemicals are likely to come off peak earnings in FY18 but declining gas costs present opportunities in ammonia production, while changes to market structure could be a catalyst for further development of downstream capabilities.

UBS agrees with the interpretation that Wesfarmers is not afraid to shrink in order to deliver superior returns and the growth outlook for the business, ex Coles, is stronger than previously thought.

The broker is now more positive on Bunnings too, expecting margins to continue widening in the near term and share gains to offset any moderation in housing.

Challenges Continue

Despite the bold action by new management in regard to the exit from the UK and the reduced scale of Target, Ord Minnett downgrades to Lighten from Hold, believing the risk/reward equation is no longer compelling.

Challenges also exist at Bunnings from the external environment, i.e. consumers and housing, and this should moderate sales growth and earnings margins, the broker asserts.

On the industrial side, the oversupply in ammonium nitrate is weighing on the company's business, and Ord Minnett also suspects that the fashion-led strategy will be difficult to achieve at Target because of tough competition.

In the end, there is a lack of valuation support, given the share price performance, and Coles is also challenged in regard to sales growth and cost pressures. The outlook for Coles appears more negative, UBS agrees, as capital expenditure is expected to rise by 20% into FY19.

Morgan Stanley also points out Coles faces headwinds from produce deflation, the new enterprise bargaining agreement and lower Coles Express earnings, while it intends to push further into private labelling, targeting 40% penetration by 2023.

Capital Returns

The company is continuing to work on the sale of its 40% stake in Bengalla and media has speculated on a sale of Kmart Tyre and Auto Services as well as a deal involving the pubs business. Macquarie points out the company has indicated these potential transactions are immaterial to the group.

Morgans suggests, if all these deals are completed, then Wesfarmers will have significant funds to invest in existing business, pursue acquisitions or return capital to shareholders.

The company is likely to wait until these divestments and the re-weighting are finalised before embarking on any M&A or capital management, the broker suspects. UBS concurs the likelihood of a capital return from the proceeds of Curragh has increased, relative to M&A.

Citi speculates that, following the Coles de-merger, Wesfarmers could undertake a $3.5bn buyback and remain in keeping with credit rating thresholds. The broker envisages a staged buyback is most likely.

Nevertheless, with the stock trading at its highest level in over three years, as investors put a premium on capital returns, the broker considers the risk of a de-rating is more imminent than earnings accretion from capital returns and retains a Sell rating.

As is the case with Citi, Morgan Stanley is not overwhelmed by the prospects and does not believe the strategy briefing changes the investment thesis. The broker believes investors will be disappointed by the lack of specific capital management and clarity over the Coles balance sheet.

FNArena's database shows four Hold ratings and three Sell. The consensus target is $43.32, suggesting -6.8% downside to the last share price. Targets range from $39 (Morgan Stanley) to $47.34 (Morgans). The dividend yield on FY18 and FY19 forecasts is 4.7% and 4.9% respectively.

See also, Wesfarmers Exits Homebase, Where Next? On May 28 2018.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms

CHARTS

WES

For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: WES - WESFARMERS LIMITED