article 3 months old

Fears For China’s Growth Postponed

FYI | Jul 21 2014

By Chen Long of GavekalDragonomics

The Chinese government has once again successfully stabilized the economy. Spooked by decelerating growth and a property market correction early in the year, the government has spent the last few months loosening credit and rolling out supportive policies. Today’s economic data release showed the pay-off: GDP growth in the second quarter picked up slightly to 7.5%, beating expectations it would be flat at 7.4%. This means that investors’ fears about a collapse in China’s economic growth can be put off for yet another year. But the success of government stimulus will not in itself answer all the concerns about China’s longer-term prospects, or provide a catalyst for the re-rating of Chinese equities.

There were several pieces of good news in the latest data release: property sales were flat after declining for three months, a sign that the recent correction may not be prolonged. Industrial production and fixed-asset investment continued to pick up. In addition, fears that widespread corporate defaults would strain the banking system have not been realized. On the bad news front, consumer spending weakened after holding up well earlier in the year. This combination points to another quarter at least of decent growth, though it will still be a stretch for China to meet its target of 7.5% GDP growth for the full year.

But there is limited potential for growth to accelerate further in the second half. And the recent stabilization may not last long since it has been driven primarily by faster credit growth and higher fiscal expenditure. The central bank has turned rather dovish and banking regulators have loosened the loan-to-deposit ratio, which led to a rebound in credit growth in May and June. Yet even the massive amounts of new credit being issued—the central bank expects aggregate financing to increase by RMB18.5trn this year!—will only push up credit growth to 18% or so by the end of the year, from 17% in June. Credit growth could well start decelerating again in early 2015. And on the fiscal side, while spending in the first half jumped 16%, the budget calls for just a 9.5% increase over the course of the year—meaning that spending growth needs to slow to 6% in the second half to stay within budget.

So while China has secured stable growth for now, by early 2015 it could well face the same problem it did earlier this year: that growth is slowing while the room to deliver additional stimulus keeps shrinking. Easy monetary policy this year means that national leverage will continue to expand. With credit growth at 18% and nominal GDP growth at best around 10% for 2014, the ratio of total credit to GDP will increase again, probably to around 240%, from 220% in 2013. This means the big question about China’s debt build-up—how long can it keep increasing leverage before financial system problems appear?—will only intensify.

The bigger picture is that China is still in the long process of finding its new natural growth rate after decades of 10%-plus growth, and there is still great uncertainty where that long-term growth will settle. The government’s biggest challenge is to convince private-sector Chinese businesses that long-term growth will be robust, and that economic reforms will open up lots of new opportunities for them. The success of its short-term economic stabilization effort does not answer these long-term questions, and the continued buildup in debt arguably increases the longer-term uncertainty. So far the government’s economic reforms, while not negligible, have not been enough to fundamentally change the private sector’s outlook: investment by private companies remains weak, and capital spending growth is now mainly supported by the state sector.

How should investors trade all this? Chinese stocks have underperformed both India and Indonesia this year, where investors appear to put more faith in the ability of new political leaders to deliver a bright economic future. But Chinese stocks have also done even worse than Thailand after its military coup, which could argue that it is time for investors to rotate into China. In the past Chinese stocks have typically rallied by 10-15% when the economy has emerged from a growth trough. However, we think such a re-rating looks unlikely this time round, since the recovery will most likely be short-lived, and China’s underlying economic problems have yet to be solved. 

 

Reprinted with permission of the publisher. Content included in this article is not by association the view of FNArena (see our disclaimer).
 

The information contained herein is provided for informational purposes only and should not be regarded as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy the securities or products mentioned. This document is a private publication intended for private distribution. The value of all investments and any income generated can decrease as well as increase. Performance numbers shown are records of past performance and as such do not guarantee future performance. No representation is made that any one investor achieved any of the results shown herein. This information is subject to change without notice. The securities and products mentioned may not be eligible for sale in some states or countries, nor suitable for all types of investors. Gavekal Research Limited does not warrant the accuracy, completeness, reliability, fitness for a particular purpose or merchantability of this information, and expressly disclaim liability for errors or omissions in this information and data. Gavekal Research Limited shall have no liability for the use, misuse, or distribution of this information to unauthorized recipients.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms